Why Your Most “Difficult” Team Member Might Just Feel Insignificant

Most disruptive employee behaviour (complaining, blaming, constant objecting) isn’t a personality flaw. It could be a signal that someone feels their presence or contribution doesn’t count. Address the sense of insignificance, and the behaviour often shifts. In this post, I explore the concept of mattering and how it affects employee engagement at work.

But before we dive in, let me show you how little it takes to make someone feel they don’t matter.

On my NLP (Neuro-Linguistic Programming) Master Practitioner course from years back – with ITS NLP – our course leader, Ian McDermott, told us about a dinner date decades ago. His girlfriend arrived, he opened the door, told her how lovely it was to see her, took her coat and showed her into the lounge. Nothing remarkable. But when Ian walked in after hanging up her coat, her eyebrows were pulled down, her gaze had sharpened, and her nostrils had flared slightly. She spent the rest of the evening in a clouded silence. He had no idea what he’d done.

I’ll tell you what I think it was at the end. But first, let’s talk about this mattering thing.

Every team has one. The person who sighs before they speak (then makes others sigh afterwards). Who finds the flaw in every plan before anyone’s finished presenting it. Who you’ve quietly stopped CC’ing on emails because, honestly, it’s easier that way. The office donkey.

We call them difficult. Negative. Toxic, even. Organisational psychologist Zach Mercurio, who researches mattering in the workplace, calls them something more useful: people who feel insignificant. His research shows that organisations which make relationships more transactional will tend to be characterised by churn, mistakes and ‘passing the buck’.

Mercurio told Atlassian that leaders often assume, without realising it, that people have to add value before they deserve to be valued. It works the other way round: people who believe they’re worthy and capable are the ones who develop the confidence to contribute.

What “mattering” has to do with difficult behaviour

Mercurio’s research shows that when people feel they don’t matter at work, because their presence, effort or voice makes no real difference, they respond in one of two ways. They withdraw. Or they react out of desperation.

Complaining, blaming and endless objecting often look like negativity, but they can be protest. Martin Luther King Jr. described riots as “the language of the unheard”, and Mercurio draws a direct line from that idea to the classic office complainer: the behaviour is the symptom.

The Quiet Kick

Not everyone who feels insignificant gets loud. Plenty go quiet. Take away the sense that anyone cares and the withdrawal makes perfect sense. Why try your hardest if nobody’s noticing? Withdrawal tends to look like this:

  • The usually enthusiastic person who stops sharing ideas
  • People isolating themselves and avoiding collaboration
  • Lateness, absence and missed meetings.

Is your difficult employee actually a narcissist?

Probably not. It’s tempting to reach for a diagnosis (“they’re a narcissist”), but even the clinical literature can’t pin down rates for Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD). A clinical reference hosted by the US National Library of Medicine puts it at up to 6.2% of US adults at some point in their lives: about one in 16.

I’d argue the real figure is probably a lot higher, since I can’t see a narcissist thinking there’s anything wrong with their behaviour that would call for assessment. I’ve worked with plenty of high-powered people who would never describe themselves that way. And as easy as it is to slap a label on someone and write them off as a lost cause, it’s the same trap as every label: it ends the curiosity.

Flip it around. Imagine you’re the one who feels unappreciated because no one acknowledges your work, and you’re short with Sonia, who wants you to do everything yesterday. Others – who don’t have the full picture – might read you as having a lack of empathy and a need for excessive admiration. Those are two of the nine criteria for NPD, and a diagnosis needs at least five. Calling you a narcissist would deny every other explanation for your behaviour.

So even at the top estimate, most of the difficult behaviour in your meetings probably has another explanation. According to Mercurio, people who feel insignificant, whether by the team, the manager or the organisational culture, are far more likely to behave in an obstructive way.

Why labelling disengaged employees backfires

To understand the underlying causes of someone’s resistant behaviour, you need to drop the labels. We cling to them tightly, mostly to pigeonhole people. Look at most talent reviews: the difficult person, the high performer, the low performer, the high potential. They feel efficient, but they’re usually a shortcut to bias, and once someone is labelled, their behaviour only becomes more entrenched.

Mercurio’s reframe is simple to say and hard to practise: swap:

“this is a difficult person” for

“this is a human being whose behaviour I’m experiencing as difficult.”

One sentence keeps the door to curiosity open. The other closes it.

What does mattering actually look like?

Mercurio’s research tells you why people act out. It doesn’t tell you what to do on Monday morning. So here is what mattering looked like for one group.

I once worked with the leadership of a council who were struggling to motivate disillusioned and obstructive staff. I used Appreciative Inquiry, a way of decoding intangibles like “morale” and “buy-in” into insight that leaders can act on strategically and tactically. Instead of listing what was wrong, I asked the group what mattered to them in specific situations, and what that mattering looked like when it was expressed. They wrote their answers on sticky notes. The same themes kept turning up:

  • Appreciation and recognition. The most repeated theme. “Gratitude.” “Feeling of appreciation.” “Recognition.” “Team appreciation.” What they told me was that they wished leaders would actually say thank you. Here are nine ways – all costing nothing – to show appreciation.
  • Being trusted. Managers “having faith and belief in the vision.” Trust is a two-way street. Here’s how to be trustworthy as well as what to expect from your team and leaders.
  • Being valued for what they bring. “Validation of my core skills, experience and passion.” Expertise, and the chance to share knowledge.
  • Belonging and safety. “Inclusive: all in it together.” “Feeling safe and the ability to be myself.”
  • Shared purpose. “A common goal, to achieve together.” “Commitment from others and collaboration.” Helping others, “the cause.” This is vision, and how leaders communicate it: people want to see the cause and where their own role fits into it.
  • Sense of learning. “Enjoy new things.”
  • Clear, concise instructions. Here are straightforward guidelines to help you become clearer: you may need to model your clarity upwards to leaders if you’re just getting waffle trickling downwards.

The Cost of Mattering:

It’s tempting to assume that showing appreciation means spending money. It doesn’t, and spending money can miss entirely. At a tech consultancy I worked at, £500 landed in everyone’s bank account as a thank-you, and it went unnoticed. When the company bought personalised gifts instead, such as books they knew each person would love, people were blown away. What landed was evidence that someone had paid attention to them as an individual.

Much of the rest of the list is behaviour rather than budget: extending trust, asking for someone’s expertise, communicating the vision clearly enough that people can see where they fit. It is also the exact opposite of insignificance. If those are the things people say they need, their absence is a plausible explanation for what leaders are reading as obstruction.

Notice how ordinary the list is. That is the same lesson as Ian’s dinner date: mattering is built from small, specific moves, and you can’t see them unless you ask.

Back to Ian

I can’t remember exactly what Ian’s offence was. My best recollection is that he walked into the lounge ahead of her, so he could hang up her coat and join her quickly. She read it as rude: the guest goes first. Ian had no idea that was a rule.

That’s the point. It looks too small to sulk over, but small moves are how people decide whether they matter: the phone call that carries on after you’ve arrived on time, the colleague who interrupts on every Teams call, the person who uses everyone’s name except yours, the guest who turns up empty-handed. What matters to one person is invisible to another.

You don’t have to understand the request. Get curious about it, and if the adjustment is small and the relationship is worth keeping, make it. The person you’re calling “difficult” may only be waiting to be let in first.

So how do you actually get curious – and find out what matters, in the first place?

  1. Ask a disengaged individual to think of someone in their own life who makes them feel like they matter, and to write down exactly what that person does – in terms of specific behaviours. For example, ‘being supportive” can mean being non-judgmental when approached for advice, or sympathetic or highlighting your work in department meetings. That tells you how to manage them. Sometime you don’t even need to ask directly: you’ll notice by how they talk – what makes them light up.
  2. Find out the root of the reaction, rather than judge the reaction: Start by swapping a conclusion for a question. For example, if anyone were to have asked: “Is there are particular reason that Sonia’s behaviour may be irritating you?”, they’d have more information. With someone who’s always negative, ask “What would make this easier?”. I promise the response would be very different from “Why are you always so negative?” Be ready for an answer you didn’t expect, because that’s the point.
  3. Ask better questions: If you want a structure for asking questions that go deeper without backing someone into a corner, use E.V.O.K.E. here.

Your Action:

  1. Most of the messages we fire off at work are task-oriented so start off by noticing how much of your interpersonal contact is transactional and around the item on your to-do list.
  2. Ensure that add more relational communication into your interactions. For example, you might want to share achievements among your team, have someone teach others in your work group a skill they have – beat boxing, or vibe coding? Doesn’t really matter.
  3. Workplace loneliness is real. Who haven’t you checked in with recently? Who do you overlook in meetings?

You don’t even have to spend equal amounts of time between the transactional and relational. Adding more of the latter to the former has an inordinate effect on cohesion, trust and the effort others are willing to make.

Need Some Personalised Support?

If you feel that disgruntled team members are creasing up morale and you’d like this ironed out, then it can be fixed.  I work with leaders, CTOs, CIOs, Department Heads, specialists in Pharma and technical leaders who need to smooth interpersonal communication because it’s difficult to lead when everyday feels like a bullfight. Have a look at my communication and influence training, or book a free 15-minute Discovery Call and let’s talk about what would make the biggest difference.

FAQ

What does it mean when an employee feels like they “don’t matter”? It means they don’t believe their presence, effort or opinion makes a meaningful difference to the team or organisation. Mercurio’s research links this feeling to withdrawal (disengagement) or desperation (complaining, conflict, blame).

What does mattering look like at work? In one council workshop, staff described it as gratitude and recognition, being trusted, having their skills and expertise valued, feeling included and safe to be themselves, learning, and working towards a common goal with clear direction. Appreciation works best when it is specific and personal: in one tech consultancy, a £500 bonus went unnoticed, while personalised gifts landed strongly.

Are difficult employees usually narcissists? Not usually. Estimates in US community samples range from 0% to about 6%, so they’re hard to pin down.” Most “difficult” behaviour has a different root cause.

What’s a practical first step for managing a disengaged or negative team member? Drop the label. Instead of thinking “this is a difficult person,” try “this is a human being whose behaviour I’m experiencing as difficult,” then get curious about what’s driving it before you manage the behaviour itself.

The takeaway

The office donkey is rarely the problem you think it is. Before you manage the behaviour, it’s worth asking what it’s protesting, and whether your team has been quietly signalling to them that they don’t matter.

Thanks to Zach Mercurio, whose research on mattering at work shaped this piece.

Photo by Joel Lee on unsplash.com

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share This: